10 Best Road Bike Saddle Bag Reviews | A comparative analysis

When we’re out for a long tour, there are certain necessary things that we need to carry. Typically we place our essentials in a suitcase or backpack. But while you’re on a long trip or a mountain ride with a bike, a suitcase or backpacks aren’t any suitable options. As while riding a bike, we have to be as burden less as possible, and not everything can be stored in the pocket. Also, carrying stuff in pockets is risky as there’re chances that they’ll fall out somewhere. That’s why a road bike saddle bag is a very important accessory for bikers who tend to go for a long ride frequently. Saddle bags are small in size, yet you can keep your essentials safe.

However, many beginner bike riders aren’t fimiliar to this accessory and don’t know what qualities to look for while buying a road bike saddlebag. That’s why today we’re here with some best road bike saddle bag in the market today to clear out all the confusion!

What are bike saddlebags used for?

You’ll have extra storage with a saddle bag, which is a good thing for carrying your essentials. Not all the bikes have a front basket, water bottle racket. As a result, carrying stuff gets complicated for a long bike commuting. But a saddlebag can quickly solve that problem of yours, especially during long rides. Some saddle bags are also wide enough to carry spare clothes, which gives you the privilege of going for a tour of 2-3 days. Some bike packing saddle bags are waterproof as well, which lets you store your mobile, torch, batteries, medicines, or other stuff safely, even if it’s pouring outside

Top 6 Best Bike Saddle Bag Reviews

1. BV Bicycle Strap on Bike Saddle Bag

BV Bicycle Strap on Bike SaddleBag

Technical Features

3M-Scotchlite reflective trim

Taillight hanger

Mesh pocket & key clip

Strap-on mounting system

Expandable feature

Key Features of BV Bicycle Strap on Bike Saddlebag

Access

While bike riding, it’s preferred to have a convenient access to the bag if you need something suddenly. You can safely keep your ride essentials in this seat pack. And this saddle bag has a zipper system on it, which lets the rider open the bag and take his/her stuff within seconds, without hampering the ride.

Safety

This bike packing saddle bag itself will work as safety equipment while you’re riding. The high-end 3M-Scotchlite reflective trim of this saddle bag gives clear visibility to other vehicle drivers from a long distance. And if you’re still not convinced by this feature, then there’s another one for extra safety, which is the Taillight hanger. It lets the rider hang a bike light so that he/she can be worriless during the night rides.

Installation

The installation process of this bike saddlebag is very easy. The bag is designed with strap-on mounting system by which you can safely attach it to the seat post or under the bike seat with the saddle rails. It has a Velcro strap that’s adjustable so that you can easily install and uninstall the bag from the bike.

Bottom Line

It’s a very impressive bicycle saddle bag designed and prepared to assist riders in making their ride more easy and comfortable. And BV has made sure that the convenience comes with both style and safety.

Let's look at the Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Available in three different sizes
  • A well-made bag
  • The reflective tape provides sufficient visibility
  • Huge storage capacity
  • Fits nicely under the bike seat 
  • The adjustable Velcro strap is handy
  • There’s an internal hook as well as mesh netting for keys

Cons

  • The bike packing saddle bag wiggles while handling
  • Seat tube strap is unnecessary long

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Is it waterproof?
    No.
  • Is it washable?
    Yes.
  • Is there any inside pocket?
    Yes, it has a clip and a mesh pocket inside.

2. Topeak Aero Wedge Velcro Pack

Topeak Aero Wedge Velcro Pack

Technical Features

Aerodynamic XS saddle bag

Velcro strap for attachment

1200 denier nylon with coating

3M Reflective Strip, Taillight strap

Large opening for easy access to the contents

Key Features of Topeak Aero Wedge Velcro Pack

Construction

It’s an aerodynamic saddle bag built with 1200 denier durable nylon and an extra coating for stain and water resistance. This saddlebag is available in four different sizes so that you can choose your preferred one. It also has a unique QuickClick mounting system, which you can replace anytime you want. This road bike saddle bag can be easily attached under the seat post of a bike.

Storage

Don’t get fooled by the outer appearance, as this bike provides an impressive amount of storage. The medium and large sizes of this bag are capable of offering up to 20-50% extra storage due to the expandability feature. It also has an extra inner compartment that offers extra space for storage in case you need to carry more things.

Zip

The zipper of this bike packing saddle bag offers a large opening. So that you won’t have to struggle much to get your things whenever you want. The zip provides the opening around the rear. There’s also a little patch of Velcro strap underneath the zipper that holds and pulls the zip when you’re closing it so that you won’t have to face the rattling.

Bottom Line

This saddlebag is pretty much the same as they advertise it, which is a good thing. It is a sturdy bag that has enough room for a pair of spare tubes, a multi tool and more. The durability, expandability, easy to use, and many other features make it perfect for traveling over a thousand-mile with your bike. It’s really one of the best saddle bags.

Let's look at the Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Easy to use and install
  • Offers impressive amount of expandability
  • Durable construction
  • Available in four different sizes
  • Not irritating movement while riding
  • The reflective strap provides proper visibility
  • Zipper provides a large opening to handle stuff easily

Cons

  • The rubber tip on the zipper got detached
  • The seat post strap is excessively long

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Does the small-sized bag expand?
    No, it’s only available in medium and large sizes
  • What’s the dimension of the small bag?
    6.7” x 4.7” x 3.1” / 17 x 12 x 8 cm
  • Is it waterproof?
    Yes.

3. Aduro Sport Bicycle Bike Storage Bag

Aduro Sport Bicycle Bike Storage Bag

Technical Features

Material: Polyester 

Adjustable Velcro straps

Big zippered opening mouth


Water and weather-resistant


Fits All Smartphones/mobile phone

No installation

Key Features of Aduro Sport Bicycle Storage Bag

Water Resistance

This road bike saddle bag is made of high-quality polyester that ensures utmost sturdiness and protects it from frequent wear and tear. The bag is water resistant as well so that you can carry your essential items even in a rainy weather without having a fear of damages.

Inner Pocket

You can carry almost all types of smartphones/mobile phone on this bag, along with other stuff. It has an inner pocket that has enough room to organize your things so that even if you suddenly need something while riding, you quickly open the zipper, which has a large opening, and get your essentials without any trouble.

Adjustable

You can easily mount this saddle bag under the seat post with its adjustable Velcro straps. The straps aren’t very long, and you can customize it just the way you want. You can do the custom fit to get the security for the bag and the stuff you’re going to carry with you. It looks really good, while riding a excellent road bike with this seat pack installed into it.

Bottom Line

Within a reasonable price, this saddle bag offers a good deal. It has a low-profile design with a slim body, which with other features, provides weather resistance as well. You can rely on this saddlebag for a bicycle in any situation for a long time.

Let's look at the Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Perfect storage capacity
  • Large zipper opening for easy access
  • Requires no extra installation
  • Both water and wind resistance
  • Gets mounted in seconds
  • Suitable for all smartphones
  • Inner pocket helps to keep things organized

Cons

  • The Velcro strap may get damaged after a while
  • Not for the bikes that already have a water mount holder

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What’s the size of the bag?
    1.89 x 9.49 x 10 inches.
  • Is this bag rugged?
    The outer side of it is thick and rugged
  • Will it fit a note 8?
    Yes.

4. BV Bicycle Y-Series Strap-On Bike Saddle Bag

BV Bicycle Y-Series Strap-On Bike Saddle Bag

Technical Features

Big zippered opening mouth

Taillight strap with 3M ScotchliteTM reflective trim

Multiple sizes option

Elastic strap inside

Mesh pocket

Key Features of BV Bicycle Y-Series Strap-On Bike Saddle Bag

Storage Capacity

This saddlebag is available in four different sizes, extra small, small, medium, and large. So that you can choose the amount of storage you need based on the sizes. Also, the storage capacity is impressively sufficient. It has room for all kinds of essentials such as a wallet, cell phones, keys, spare tube, bike lock, mini pump, repair kit and even the large bags might allow you to carry one or two spare clothes as well.

Taillight Compatible

If you don’t have a light attached on the bike, then no worries, as you can do it with the saddlebag. This road bike saddle bag doesn’t only helps you to carry your essential stuffs, but also it lets you attach a Taillight on the bag so that you can ensure your maximum visibility during night rides. However, you have to attach the light separately. But still, it has a reflector trim, which will work pretty well even without a light.

Zipper

The big opening mouth that the zipper offers is very convenient. It helps to have easy access inside the bag, even with a light attached to the bag. Also, there’s an electric strap and mesh pocket inside, which helps keep small things such as keys, batteries, screws, etc. safely so that you don’t lose them and find them when needed.

Bottom Line

It’s indeed one of the best saddlebags you would like to have for your backpacking trip. From storage, easy access to safety, it doesn’t have any mentionable faults. The sizes are also convenient for different bike riders. You can just choose your suitable one.

Let's look at the Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Fits well to the bike
  • Installation is easy
  • You can carry almost all kinds of essential with the big storage capacity
  • Build quality is excellent and long-lasting
  • Taillight compatible for night ride security
  • Doesn’t move unnecessarily while riding
  • Elastic strap and mesh pocket helps for easy organizing

Cons

  • The zipper is a bit complicated to handle
  • Stitches are uneven around the bag

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What’s the dimension of size medium?
    7.5 in x 4.0 in x 4.0 inches
  • Is it waterproof?
    Not really. It can’t handle massive rain/water splash.
  • Does this bag has a Velcro strap?
    No.

5. Roswheel Race Series 131432 Ultralight Bike Saddle Bag

Roswheel Race Series 131432 Ultralight Bike Saddle Bag

Technical Features

Streamline design 

Air & wind resistance 

Ultra-light fabric 

3-quality Velcro strap

Reflective element and taillight loop

Key Features of Roswheel Race Series 131432 Ultralight Bike Saddle Bag

Streamline Design

Many think that attaching a saddlebag under the seat post will reduce the speed of the bike. But with this seat pack, there’s no way to think of that. It has a streamlined design that decreases air and wind resistance as much as possible. As a result, the speed of the bike doesn’t get affected, even it increases. Also, the ultra-light fabric has made the bag 30% lighter than other saddlebags, which is pretty convenient as well.

Security

The security of this road bike saddle bag is quite impressive. It has three Velcro straps that give maximum security even while you’re on rough terrain. Also, many bikers complain that a long Velcro strap creates issues for a perfect fit. But here, you can clip the length of the straps according to your need.

Taillight Compatible

Taillight compatibility is something that all the bike riders want in a saddlebag. And this one here won’t disappoint you on that matter. It has a taillight hanger where you can easily attach the light and ensure your visibility at night. Even both sides of this seat pack has got reflective logos to increase visibility in low light.

Bottom Line

This bike is worthy of being mentioned as one of the best saddlebags for bike based on all the features. Almost all the features you’ll find in most saddlebags as well, but the streamlined design and ultra-light fabric have made this one of the best seat packs.

Let's look at the Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Streamline design for increased acceleration
  • Ultra-light fabric
  • Enhanced security with 3-point Velcro straps
  • Taillight hanger for safe night rides
  • Metal zipper with easy access
  • Easy installation and quick release
  • Durable quality with maximum wear and tear resistance

Cons

  • The zipper sometimes opens up automatically while riding
  • The light holder isn’t strong enough 

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Is this bag waterproof?
    No
  • Does it have reflective elements?
    Yes.
  • Is it right for mountain riding?
    Yes.

6. ROCKBROS Bike Seat Waterproof Bicycle Saddle Bag

ROCKBROS Bike Seat Waterproof Bicycle Saddle Bag

Technical Features

Reflective ring-bone 

Thick 3D diving cotton 

One-piece reinforced upgraded strap 

Taillight hook and reflective strips 

Elastic rubber

Key Features of ROCKBROS Bike Seat Waterproof Bicycle Saddle Bag

Special Shape

The shape of this saddle bag is quite unique. This saddle bag’s cushioning has a wave shape that works as shock-resistant protection for stuff inside the bag and protection from the outside if the bag fell off. As a result, you can be completely worriless about the things you’re going to carry with you. The oblique shape allows one to fit things like multi tool kit or inner tube, patch kit like most saddle bags.

Water Resistant Quality

It’s essential to have a waterproof saddle for the security of the necessities you intend to carry because you never know when the weather gets vulnerable while you’re on a long tour. Here this saddle bag is made of waterproof fabric, and even it has water resistant zip as well. Although the stitches are not waterproof, so don’t keep it wet for a long time.

Easy to install

There’re two stickup straps along with a rubber buckle to make the installation process super easy. Whether you’re mounting the saddlebag with the seat post or under the seat post, you won’t face any complications while mounting it.

Bottom line

The design of this road bike saddle bag is very attractive, and the features are superb as well and can be used for mountain bike also. Its well detailed mesh pockets can fit phone, cash, keys, energy bars etc. From a secure fitting to waterproof feature everything can be done with utmost comfort with this saddlebag.

Let's look at the Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Thick cotton with wave-shaped cushioning to reduce corrosion and outer protection
  • Easy to install
  • Provides sufficient amount of storage
  • Suitable for a safe night ride
  • Suitable for all-weather condition with water resistant quality
  • Elastic rubber for easy replacement between bikes
  • The design very stylish

Cons

  • The stitches are not waterproof
  • It’s hard to crunch down the bag

Frequently Asked Questions

  • How much weight can the strap bear?
    4kg.
  • Does it have mesh or main pocket?
    Yes.
  • Does it come with a light?
    No.

Things to Consider

Material

The material determines the longevity of a product. That’s why it’s better to know about the material a saddlebag can be made of and what type is the best. It also determines if the bag is waterproof or not. Usually, there are four types of materials used in in saddlebag for road bikes. Nylon is the most popular is its waterproof and available at a reasonable price. Then comes polyester, which is famous for its wear and tear resistance, in a word, it's extremely durable; making sure the bag will last for a long time. After that, leather is also used to make a saddlebag, and it’s durable as well. However, it’s a bit expensive than bags prepared for other materials. And lastly, there’s synthetic, which works excellent for waterproof facility and durable as well. So, it is important for the saddle pack to be made of top quality and durable materials.

Size

Saddlebags come in various sizes, big, small, medium, etc. If you ask what size is best, then there’s no definite answer for that. Because the perception of perfect size varies from person to person and the duration of bike commuting. If you think your necessary things would require a large bag, that’s suitable for you. And if you think a small saddlebag will work for you then go for that one. Usually, if a bike rider is out for an extended tour, it’s better to have a large or medium sized bag.

Installation

Different road bike saddle bags have different installation procedures. Although look for a bag that’s easy to put on and off. Some saddle bags have straps, which are considered to be the most convenient. On the other hand, some bags have thick and non-flexible buckles, which are annoying. Although no matter what, try to go for that one sturdy and robust buckle that will provide enough security while experience extreme rides with huge bumps and shocks.

Add-ons 

Add-ons such as trail loops or reflective stripes are very useful in saddlebags. It gives you extra visibility while riding at night so that others can notice you, and you can avoid any accident. Also, clips for keys are convenient as well for keeping them secure.

Multiple Compartments or a Single Storage 

Saddlebags can have multiple compartments or can have only single storage. It actually depends on the design. If you’re going to carry more stuff for your bike commuting, then multiple compartments are better as it helps organize appropriately. But if there are only a few things you need for your ride, single compartment saddlebags will be more flexible.

Conclusion

Bike riders are mostly adventure lovers, so they roam around different exceptional places. And those who are professional riders they mostly go for a long trip of 2-3 days. And we all know while going for a long journey with a bike it’s not possible to carry a suitcase or backpack as it’s not convenient at all. But at the same time, there’re a few essentials that you must take for your safety during the ride, and as those are only a few stuff, you need to maintain their security. That’s why a bike saddle bag is always necessary to have so that you can be worriless and enjoy the adventure you’re looking forward to having.